WSE MARKET DESK
MKT ▲ECON ▲INV ▲BANK ▲CRYPTO ▲
▲ MarketsWSE Research Note

Nvidia's Harvey Jones Is Failing Shareholders on Jensen Huang

Nvidia is down 39% from its record. Opinion: board chair Harvey Jones ruled out Jensen Huang's return before the facts were in, and shareholders are paying for it.

By Gregory Haas
Nvidia's Harvey Jones Is Failing Shareholders on Jensen Huang

Opinion.

Nvidia closed at $145.98 on November 19. On October 6 it closed at a record $239.24. That is a 39% fall in six weeks for the world's most valuable chipmaker. Not all of it belongs to the board. The slide began with reports about Jensen Huang's private life, and Huang made those mistakes himself. But since Harvey C. Jones became Nvidia's first-ever board chair on November 12, the board's choices have become the story, and those choices have been short-sighted.

What the board actually did

The record is short and it is public.

On November 8, Nvidia's board announced an independent inquiry into Huang's relationship with Alice Huang, an executive at the cloud company Megaspeed whom U.S. officials reportedly suspect of gathering information for China. The board said it had no reason to believe national security or company secrets had been compromised, and it expressed confidence in Huang. On November 11, according to its SEC filing, it accepted his resignation, effective immediately. It named CFO Colette Kress interim CEO and Jones chair.

Six days later, on the November 17 earnings call, Jones said the board "unanimously" accepted the resignation and "does not intend to reinstate Jensen as CEO," Forbes reported. He took no questions about why Huang left or about the investigation, which is still open. He named no timeline for a permanent CEO. The board has retained Heidrick & Struggles to run the search.

So in nine days the board went from confidence to resignation to a permanent no, while its own inquiry had not reported.

What it cost

Nvidia daily closing price from October 1 to November 19, 2026, falling from a record $239.24 on October 6 to $145.98 on November 19, with the board's November 8, 12 and 17 decisions marked

Source: Yahoo Finance daily closes. Method: each figure is the closing price on the date shown, compared with the October 6 record close.

Date Event Close From record
Oct 6 Record close $239.24 0.0%
Nov 6 Last close before the board's Nov 8 statement $186.64 −22.0%
Nov 11 Last close before Huang's exit was announced $173.73 −27.4%
Nov 12 Huang out, Jones named chair $166.19 −30.5%
Nov 17 Jones rules out reinstatement on earnings call $155.46 −35.0%
Nov 19 Latest confirmed close $145.98 −39.0%

From the last close before Harvey Jones took the chair ($173.73 on November 11) to November 19 ($145.98), Nvidia fell 16.0% in six trading sessions. That fall came through a quarter that should have stopped it. Nvidia reported $115.8 billion in third-quarter revenue and $2.68 in diluted earnings per share against an expected $2.47, and guided to about $130 billion for the next quarter. The shares rose about 5% after hours on those numbers. Then they kept falling.

The business is not the problem. The market is pricing the leadership, and the leadership is now the board's responsibility.

To be fair to the other side, the stock also slipped on November 16 on reports that Huang was weighing a comeback. Investors want certainty more than they want any particular name. But certainty is exactly what the board has failed to supply. It closed one door permanently and has not opened another.

Shareholders are saying it out loud

This is not a lone complaint. Bill Ackman wrote on X that "the @nvidia board is not acting in the best interest of shareholders nor in a manner consistent with their fiduciary duties," and told Business Insider that the directors "rushed to judgment without the benefit of careful due diligence." Elon Musk said the decision not to bring Huang back "doesn't seem like a smart decision," 24/7 Wall St. reported.

On November 20, Methuselah Advisors sent an open letter addressed to "Chairman Jones" calling the separation "an extraordinary failure of corporate stewardship" and asking the question the board has not answered: "What changed?" Between November 8 and November 11, the board went from confidence in Huang to accepting his exit. It has not said what it learned in those three days.

Even inside the boardroom the line is not as solid as Jones presented it. Semafor reported that a subset of directors is still pushing for Huang's return, according to the Forbes timeline. "Unanimously" described the vote to accept a resignation. It does not describe the board's view of what comes next.

Judging Harvey Jones

Jones has a real résumé. He ran Synopsys as CEO and executive chairman, co-founded Daisy Systems and Tensilica, and has sat on Nvidia's board since 1993, according to his Nvidia biography. Former colleagues told Fortune he is a "charming elder statesman" who is "very hard to ruffle."

A résumé is not the same as judgment in the job, and the job he has done so far falls short in three ways.

He ruled out the option before the facts were in. The board's own investigation is open. California's attorney general has served a subpoena, and Huang is due to testify to Congress in December. Announcing "does not intend to reinstate" before any of that concludes gives away leverage and choice for nothing. If the inquiry clears Huang of any national-security problem, the board has already promised not to act on that finding. That is the core of Ackman's complaint, and it is a sound one.

He has explained almost nothing. Shareholders have lost roughly two-fifths of their investment since October. On the one call where the chair spoke to them, he refused questions on the subject they cared about most. A chair who cannot say what changed between November 8 and November 11 is asking for trust he has not yet earned.

He was on the watch for 33 years. Nvidia operated without a board chair and without a public succession plan until the day it needed both. Fortune asked whether Jones is the right person to ride out the storm or partly responsible for it. Jones served through the years in which the conduct now under investigation took place. Directors with that much tenure should be the last people to claim the crisis caught them by surprise.

What we don't know

We do not know why Harvey Jones chose a permanent no. There is no public evidence of a personal grudge between Jones and Huang, and we are not claiming one. Jones himself owns about 0.03% of Nvidia, and Forbes says his billionaire status is "almost entirely due to his Nvidia director's compensation," so he has lost money in this slide too.

What we can judge is the result. For whatever reason, Nvidia's board under Harvey Jones has put a fast, irreversible statement ahead of a careful process. Shareholders have paid for that choice in the share price. Shareholders are entitled to ask whether a chair who has just been handed a newly created role is weighing the board's own position more heavily than their returns. Until Jones answers that, the most charitable reading of his chairmanship is that it has been short-sighted.

Our verdict: on the evidence of its first nine days, Harvey Jones's chairmanship has not been acting in the shareholders' best interest, and Nvidia's shareholders deserve a reinstatement decision made after the facts, not before them.

Cover image: AI-generated illustration of an empty boardroom. It does not depict Nvidia's offices.